
Frank Miller is an important figure for nerds my age. He created dark Daredevil and Batman stories that changed superhero comics forever. And look, it’s not really Miller’s fault that his influence changed superhero comics for the worse. Lesser creators took the wrong lessons from his work, assuming that people wanted nothing but cruelty and cynicism in their comics.
But more importantly, when Miller moved into creator-owned work, he pulled a lot of us superhero fans away from Marvel and DC and into independent comics along with him—a genuine change for the better. So it was crushing to see Miller swerve into conservatism with 300 and, most of all, the Islamophobic hate comic Holy Terror. In a handful of decades, he veered from young punk cartoonist to a champion of anti-corporate comics to a moral monster who seemed irrevocably broken by 9/11.
So I’m sad to report that Miller’s new memoir, Push the Wall, isn’t as introspective as I’d need to change how I feel about the man. He addresses Holy Terror a bit, but I found his reasoning shallow and ineffective. And in fact the book is remarkably shallow—Miller’s thoughts on his old work feel bland and perfunctory, and his recollections of important life events are vague and anodyne.
Miller is most alive when he’s talking about the process of making the Sin City movies with Robert Rodriguez, which is to me perhaps the least interesting part of his career. I’d rather hear more than a handful of sentence about the making of the Martha Washington series of comics with Dave Gibbons, or some thoughts about his contemporaries and how their careers have panned out.
Sadly, this book isn’t even a good resource for artists looking to break into comics. Aside from a few observations about the utility of tall vertical panels and the controlled chaos of using a toothbrush to spray the page with ink, there are not enough artistic lessons here to be useful. The whole time, Miller feels reluctant to share his story, giving the impression of a fawning convention panel with a tired old professional who just desperately wants to get back to his hotel so he can leave San Diego and get back to what he was doing before all this bullshit pulled him away from the drawing board.






