
I kept waiting for the protagonist of Sandwich, the bestselling novel from Catherine Newman, to admit that she had a drinking problem.
Admittedly, as someone who has been sober for 17 years, I’m acutely aware of depictions of drinking in entertainment. And I’m not afraid to acknowledge that I can be a little bit judgey when I see fictional characters abuse alcohol in a dangerous way.
But Rocky, the matriarch of the family in Sandwich, experiences multiple instances in this short novel in which she drinks too much and admits harmful dark secrets in public at the worst possible time. There’s a scene where she blacks out drinking during game night and pisses off her whole family, insulting her husband and getting enraged at everyone. She wakes up the next morning and sheepishly apologizes to everyone. I naturally assumed the story was heading to an intervention.
Spoiler alert: There’s no such intervention in Sandwich. Rocky’s drinking is apparently supposed to be an endearing character flaw, like the romcom heroine who is beautiful and intelligent and just a wee bit clumsy.
Look, I’m not the intended audience for this book. It’s about a family on their annual Cape Cod vacation, and the humor is a slightly more ribald version of the standard sitcom variety, with lots of menopause jokes peppered throughout. And like a sitcom, there’s always an underlying affirmation in Sandwich that families and love will conquer all. That sentiment is hovering below all the characters like a safety net on a high-wire act.
So if you’re looking for a gentle and affirming story about a generic upper middle class white family vacationing on Cape Cod, I’m not one to begrudge you. It’s a summery confection. I listened to the novel on audiobook, and I was never bored.
But just promise me one thing: If you find yourself relating to Rocky’s relationship with alcohol, please consider taking a couple of months off the bottle and maybe see how you feel afterward? Like the dialogue from many of the characters in Sandwich, this warning may sound cruel or dismissive, but it comes from a place of love.






